Preview · data is being verified · analytical ratings are labeled opinions

City

Nicole McDermott

Granite School Board (President) · Precinct 4

OfficeGranite School Board (President)DistrictPrecinct 4PartyNonpartisan office (R nominee for State School Board D8)Term endsDec 31, 2028Next electionNov 3, 2026 (State School Board D8)RaisedNot yet verifiedServing since2019

At a glance

  • Granite Board of Education, Precinct 4, since 2019; Board President since 2023.
  • Won 2024 re-election with 76.2%.
  • Republican nominee for State School Board District 8 on Nov 3, 2026, vs. Araueni Olivares (D).
  • Campaign-finance totals not retrieved (portals CAPTCHA-gated).
Open compare
Analytical assessment, not factLow confidence
OverallLean conservative
FiscalConservative
SocialLean conservative
Very liberalModerateVery conservative

Lean conservative (mainstream, establishment Utah Republican)

Evidence behind this assessment
  • Party: she is the Republican nominee for State Board of Education D8 in 2026, having won the primary 58.82% to 41.18% (results).
  • Self-description (campaign site):
    • "fiscally conservative policies"
    • parental rights
    • "Keeping Politics Out of Classrooms"
    • educational choice
    • local control
    • fewer regulations
  • Tax votes:
    • Voted Yea on Granite's 10.26% (about $21.1M) tax increase and the 2026-27 budget, each 6-1 (minutes, Aug 18, 2026).
    • Voted Yea on the June 16, 2026 preliminary rate (minutes).
    • As a resident, spoke in support of Taylorsville's 2024 25% increase (minutes).
  • Natalie Cline resolution: she led the board's 6-1 resolution urging State Board member Natalie Cline to resign: "the gravity of this incident compels us to act" (Utah News Dispatch). This places her in the institutional, mainstream wing rather than the insurgent right.
  • X mention: a 2019 post by a Granite teacher: "CBE is a national trend. Nicole McDermott glad to see Granite... doing PBG already" (post). This shows interest in competency-based education reform; it is ideologically neutral.
  • Own X account: none found.

Rating method

Ask about this official's record

Answers are estimates of likely positions based only on this official's public record (votes, bills, statements and posts) as stored on this site. They are not statements by the official and may be incomplete. Check the linked sources.

Ask your own question about Nicole McDermott

Full details below are grouped by area. Facts link to public sources; "[COMPUTED]" marks derived dates.

Votes & record

Source: Granite Board of Education minutes on the Utah Public Notice Website, body 767.

Date Item Her vote / result Source
Feb 2024 Resolution calling on State Board member Natalie Cline to resignWhat it does: Would call on State Board member Natalie Cline to resign. A Yea vote supported doing that. council minutes Passed 6-1; she was quoted in support Utah News Dispatch
Nov 18, 2025 Suspension of the Area 5 school-closure studyWhat it does: Would suspend the study on closing schools in Area 5. A Yea vote supported doing that. Unanimous KSL coverage; PMN body 767
Jun 16, 2026 Preliminary tax rate and budget-related motionWhat it does: Official item text: Preliminary tax rate and budget-related motion. A Yea vote supported doing that. council minutes Each passed 6-1 (Kim Chandler No); McDermott Yea minutes
Aug 18, 2026 Truth-in-Taxation: rate 0.006133 (10.26% increase, about $21.1M), and 2026-27 budget adoptionWhat it does: Official item text: Truth-in-Taxation: rate 0.006133 (10.26% increase, about $21.1M), and 2026-27 budget adoption. A Yea vote supported doing that. council minutes Each passed 6-1 (Chandler No); McDermott Yea; she presided minutes; Fox13
Sep 1, 2026 Precinct 1 vacancy appointment: motions to call the question on Elena Leppard's appointmentWhat it does: Would appoint Elena Leppard to fill the Precinct 1 vacancy. This vote decided whether to end discussion and vote right away. A Yea vote supported voting right away. council minutes Failed 3-4; McDermott voted with Jackson and Nelson. Leppard was ultimately appointed unanimously minutes
  • Public comment as a resident: At the Taylorsville City Council's Aug 21, 2024 Truth-in-Taxation hearing, she spoke in support of the city's proposed tax increase (minutes).
Campaign finance
  • Local school board (2018, 2020, 2024): Granite board candidates file with the Salt Lake County Clerk.
    • The county's local school board financial disclosures page lists her 2018 interim reports and her 2020 April, June, Sept, and Year-End reports. The underlying filings are hosted on disclosure.slco.org, which was unreachable.
    • 2024 reports are in the county's EasyVote public portal, which requires a CAPTCHA.
    • Totals not retrieved. This is a gap.
  • State Board of Education 2026: candidates file with the Lieutenant Governor's office at disclosures.utah.gov. The portal blocks automated access. Totals not retrieved. This is a gap.
  • Headline: no campaign-finance figures could be verified.
Disclosures
  • Her Granite board conflict-of-interest disclosure (required for school board members under Utah law and district policy) was not retrieved. This is a gap.
  • State Board candidate disclosures, if any, are on disclosures.utah.gov and were not retrieved.
Election history
Year Office Result Source
2018 Granite Board, Precinct 4 Won: 7,986 (57.49%) vs. incumbent Carrie Soderstrom Johnson, 5,905 SLCo 2018 general
2020 Granite Board, Precinct 4 Won, unopposed: 18,227 SLCo 2020 general results (saltlakecounty.gov historical results)
2024 Granite Board, Precinct 4 Won: 15,073 (76.15%) vs. Todd William Morrill, 4,722 2024 SLCo canvass
2026 (primary) State Board of Education D8 (R) Won: 5,780 (58.82%) vs. Trina Christensen, 4,047 official results
2026 (general) State Board of Education D8 Pending Nov 3, 2026, vs. Araueni Olivares (D) same
Lobbying & ethics
  • No lobbyist ties found in the public records reviewed. lobbyist.utah.gov was not successfully searched.
  • No ethics complaint found in the materials reviewed.
Office & term
  • Office: Member, Granite School District Board of Education, Precinct 4. Board President. Term ends Dec 31, 2028. (Granite Board page)
  • Board President since: January 2023 (Granite School District on X).
  • Precinct 4 schools (per the Granite Board page):
    • Bennion, Fox Hills, Smith, and Truman elementaries
    • Bennion Jr., Eisenhower, Jefferson, and Kearns Jr.
    • Kearns High and Taylorsville High
  • Service: first elected Nov 2018, taking office January 2019. Re-elected 2020 and 2024.
  • Next election for this seat: November 2028 [COMPUTED].
  • Pending candidacy: She is the Republican nominee for Utah State Board of Education, District 8, on the Nov 3, 2026 general ballot against Araueni Olivares (D). If she is elected, the Precinct 4 seat would presumably be vacated and filled under state law [inference, not verified].
Stated affiliation
  • Party: Granite board races are nonpartisan, and the 2024 Salt Lake County canvass shows her as "(UNA)" (2024 canvass). The 2026 State Board of Education race is partisan, and she won the Republican primary on June 23, 2026 (official results).
  • Self-description (campaign Issues and About pages):
    • "fiscally conservative policies"
    • parental rights
    • "Keeping Politics Out of Classrooms"
    • educational choice
    • local control
    • reducing regulations
  • Public statement as Board President: In February 2024, Granite's board passed a 6-1 resolution calling on State Board member Natalie Cline to resign. McDermott said the board "seldom passes resolutions; the gravity of this incident compels us to act." (Utah News Dispatch, Feb 9, 2024)
Contact (official)
Known gaps

Gaps

  • 2018, 2020, and 2024 campaign finance reports. Custodian: Salt Lake County Clerk (Elections Division).
  • 2026 State Board campaign finance reports. Custodian: Lieutenant Governor's Office, Elections. They are public online, but automated access is blocked.
  • Granite board conflict-of-interest disclosure. Custodian: Granite School District, Business Administrator / Board Secretary.
  • Full vote history before 2026 (Granite minutes 2019–2025 were not systematically reviewed).
  • Ethics complaints. Custodian: Granite School District.
About this office: Granite School Board member

One of seven part-time, nonpartisan board members who set policy, the budget and the property tax rate for Granite School District (about 52,000 students), and who hire and oversee the superintendent.

Role
Local school board member, elected by precinct
Hours
Part-time
Pay
about $10,444
Typical week
Two Tuesday evening board meetings a month (5 p.m. reports, 7 p.m. general session), school visits, committees; budget hearing in June and tax hearing in August

Responsibilities and powers

  • State law requires a local board to implement the state core standards, give the required tests and use the results to plan improvement, issue grades, build early-warning systems for struggling students, and train administrators (Utah Code 53G-4-402).
  • The Granite board "holds public meetings once or twice monthly to establish district policies, approve purchases and budgets, receive reports from district administrators, approve administrative appointments, and conduct other business" (Granite Board of Education).
  • Budget and taxes: adopts the district budget (2026–27: $951.8 million in total expenditures) and any property tax increase after a truth-in-taxation hearing (Granite budget development; 2026–27 budget).
  • Seven members, elected by precinct to four-year nonpartisan terms (Granite Board). Taylorsville is mostly in Precincts 3 and 4, with a sliver in 6.

A typical week

  • Meetings: the 2026 schedule has regular board meetings on the first Tuesday of most months (administrative reports 5:00 p.m., general session 7:00 p.m.), study sessions about two weeks later, a June 16 budget hearing, an Aug. 18 truth-in-taxation hearing, and spring executive sessions for employee negotiations (2026 Board Meeting Schedule). Meetings are at the Granite Education Center, 2500 S State, and broadcast online.
  • Seasonal cycle: spring negotiations and budget building, the interim budget in June, the tax hearing in August, and reports on fall enrollment (52,197 projected for fall 2026, down 2,270) (2026–27 budget).
  • Between meetings [INFERRED]: reading board packets, visiting schools in the precinct, answering parent emails and calls, attending school community council and graduation events, and committee work.

Time commitment

  • Part-time, roughly 5–15 hours a week [INFERRED from two evening meetings a month plus preparation and school visits]. Most members hold other jobs.

Staff and budget

  • No personal staff. The board directs the superintendent and district administration, who run a $951.8 million budget for about 52,000 students (2026–27 budget).

Pay

  • About $10,444 a year (one member's FY2026 record). Members may join district health, dental and life plans, and expenses are reimbursed. Pay was set in 2019 at 20% of a first-year teacher's salary ($8,696 then) (Transparent Utah; Granite 2019 compensation hearing).

Sources

Compare with every office →

Sources